Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John's avatar

I'm generally optimistic myself, and a firm believer in "the power of positive thinking" - not the woo woo aspects of "The Secret", but the part where positive expectancy increases the odds you'll recognize and act upon good opportunities, and surround yourself with like-minded people, which is a virtuous cycle.

But I take exception to this:

> "3. Technology always incites fear. Every technological leap from the printing press to the internet has sparked intense fears of widespread job loss and social collapse. Artificial intelligence is no different"

Artificial intelligence is very different.

There is a significant probability that we will achieve Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) and Artificial Super Intelligence (ASI) combined with robotics within the next few years to decades.

If and when we do, we will have created the dominant species on Earth, supplanting humans as the dominant species - something fundamentally unlike any prior technological leap. When a species has supplanted another as the dominant species, it rarely goes well for the supplanted species.

This is not remotely like any other technological leap from the past. *All* jobs will be performed cheaper, faster, and more accurately by ASI and robots than humans with the exception of people paying a premium for human service or human produced (a niche when the price will be far higher than the equivalent AI/robotic equivalent). See https://youtu.be/7Pq-S557XQU?is=SqJVFdG-9nNXx54M (Humans Need Not Apply).

Could this result in a world of hyperabundance for all? Sure. Could it cause social collapse due to massive unemployment if the economics aren't worked out? Yes, that is also possible.

Hopefully the future will be closer to the former than the later, but past technological leaps are so different in scale and nature that they provide little comfort that it will.

Ready for more?